Spot Check: Makin' a list - Checkin' it twice. Naughty? Nice? Santa's working on it. 2022 – Winnetka's Year in Review.

Tickets to Reindeer Games? Coal in their collective stockings?

Here. Comes. Santa.

Each Spring, the Winnetka Caucus Council floats the Annual Survey – and our DIY government delivers truth to power. If you're one of the 1,205 residents who took this year's survey, way to nail the Nice List.

But the Taxing Boards to whom the subsequent Platforms get delivered? Santa's working on it.


D36 School Board – Benchmarks, Safety, and Sex Ed.

Benchmarking’s big. In 2021 (70%), and again in 2022 (74%) you wanted to know how prepared D36 kids are compared to other New Trier feeder schools.

 See you, raise you, said the District. Signed with ECRA Group. Benchmarks kids against their peers and against themselves, creates a learning profile for each child then measures projected vs actual. Even talks ROI and will help "recapture learning lost through the pandemic." In their own words… Might also help with the “data testing vs progressive learning” ball toss – 34 Survey comments for progressive education; 22 for more “traditional methods.”

Too late for the Survey, just in time for the referendum. After July 4th, safety and security took top billing on the District’s to-do. On September 20th, the Board adopted a "Safe, Secure and Healthy Schools Resolution" then hired a "third party resource" called " Text for Help" to give kids and their families 24/7 immediate and anonymous access to licensed clinicians.

Sex Ed. Made it to the Governor's desk, but not the Survey. Concerned parents referred to it obliquely in the comments as a desire to return to the basics. To which Superintendent Tess issued this – keeping in place the plan they’ve had since 2020. No new classes added. “Aligns with the national standards."

Santa's wondering what they're solving for here, but likes the caution with which the board and Super are moving.

Safe Schools, 24/7 crisis hotline, referendum? Nice List. Full stop.

Library Board – An Embarrassment of Riches, Spending Few Know About – and This Just In.

The District had money. Too much. Whether from overtaxing or canceling projects it didn’t think were must-dos for the Northfield Branch, it's cash that needed to be stashed before auditors started side-eyeing. So they created a reserve to fund projects-to-be-determined. Sixty percent of you Survey-takers said keep the levy flat until that surplus is reduced to a best-practice six months of operating expenses. On November 14th, they did.

You also wanted the Lib to buy the eponymous park to the East. So, they did that, too. "Kind of defensively…” $313,000. Here’s the deal and discussion.

They say they “have no plans for it” but there it is. The Park's little piece of green space best cased in the Facilities part of the Strategic Plan – the Strat Plan 47% of you said you didn't know about or weren’t feeling it. The Board calls it “space planning.” With its potential $15M price tag for Northfield and Winnetka, the Elves bet it has your attention now.

After checking out the Plan, the Presentation, and the suggested rollout, Santa joins the Board, Consultant, and Elves in the maybe-too-much-of-a-good thing column. Is this "a clearer and more convincing value proposition for the strategic plan" called for in the Platform? Thoughts welcome here.

For years, residents have said services were fine, just let more people know more about them. So they ramped up their www, started video-ing their meetings and posting their agenda packets. Major Elfin kudos here.

Just in – the auditors’ report for Fiscal 2022. They say it’s “a clean audit.” Meaning the Lib's spent its reserves down to one year's expenses. On what, the Elves wonder. More than two years'? Auditors will be back.

Santa's thinking Nice List for now. Pencil poised. Waiting to see if the call for "public information sessions clarifying the objectives of the strategic plan" and more, happens.

Park District Board – Sharpen your Pencils, People over Pets, and The Pool.

Too complicated? Too on-going? Not enough info? Whatever, the subject of the Park Board’s last two years – the future of the Centennial/Elder waterfront – didn’t make the Survey. Two years of closed-door sessions can do that.

What did were more-than-suggestions to “go back and sharpen your pencils.” And calls for public access, food trucks, beach seating, watercraft rental, potties, and to put “people over pets.” Oops. On October 27th, the Board voted to amend the Lakefront Plan to put the dog beach back in – "not less than 170 feet and not greater than 270 feet" of dog beach back in.

Then, the Board called it. Four-to-three vote. As of January 20, 2023, the District plans to swap 261 Sheridan Road for 70 feet of Centennial Park. In spite of a lawsuit, that says, um, maybe not yours to swap. The Elves say it's never too late to comment. Otherwise, details TBD.

Wouldn't be a Caucus Survey without this: The perennial pool question delivered the perennial 50-50 answer and the perennial platform direction to study its viability. Ooo-kay...

And this: The multi-year call for transparency among all taxing boards delivered the District’s new website, taped meetings, and a new portal for its meetings and materials.

This is a tough one for Santa. On the one hand, an attempt to come clean in public; on the other hand, 2 years of playing with millions of taxpayer dollars behind closed doors.

Santa's sticking a pin in this one until he sees how the Board handles the land swap lawsuit. Maybe there'll be something interesting in his mailbox.

Village Council – One Winnetka, Diversity, Greenspace, and Storefronts.

The Number One Conundrum is one step closer to done. Nothing to survey, but plenty of "get it done, for Pete's sake." On October 18th, the VC heard the developer's latest version: 53'6" high – or less, on-street and underground parking,18,8000 sq. ft. of commercial, 48 two-to-three-bedroom units. Rental. Tudor – or Tudor-esque. "Guaranteed to fit into the neighborhood." Next up: The just-purchased Conney's Pharmacy joins the plan, back to the VC (dateline: January 2023), lock down architecture and construction methods, then file a planned development application. Elves are feelin' it. Santa's crossing fingers.

Diversity. A term with a dozen meanings. Almost 23% of residents rated it among their top three areas for improvement. They're in luck. It's in the soon-to-be-approved Comp Plan – so you'll see it in some form on some agenda sooner or later.

Survey-takers want eyes on "mature trees and green spaces, pursuing opportunities to install green infrastructure and native plants..." Elves approve of working with The Friends of the Green Bay Trail because, well, greenspace is important when you come from the Tundra.

Economic Development's still on everybody's mind. The Platform says to get with "regional economic agencies, real estate developers, business associations, and business owners to ensure Winnetka is an attractive place to do business." Santa's like, "where have you been?" Liz Dechant and the Village's Economic Development Department's been on this for years. Think Pomeroy, Serena and Lily. We join Santa in the Big Fan Department: We covered Liz's work here and here.

The Stormwater Solution. Top of the list in surveys past, signed, sealed and being delivered. Flood control, no new taxes, and a lotta new friends in high places. Santa's been waiting 11 years to high-five the VC. He's thinking tickets to Reindeer Games.

No way to survey, but a major judge of character: Last week, the VC heard Mr. Land Swap's request for a consolidation of his four lakefront properties into an "authentic suburban experience" for his family. They approved it on its compliance with Winnetka's laws and ordinances – ignoring his lawyer's full frontal accusations of personal bias and more.

Way to earn Santa's admiration – a place squarely on the Nice List. The lawyer? Not so much.


Visions of Sugarplums.

The Number 1 Plank on each of the Platforms was to play nice with one another. Called "Collaborative Cost Reduction," it wants each board to identify "opportunities for efficiencies and cost savings for the taxpayers of Winnetka."

Right now, the Parks and Schools are working on programming for Crow Island's new gym; although the Elves are side-eying the Park's mission to preserve green space, the Library's helping Parks raise capital for its Lakefront projects by buying Library Park; Schools, Parks and Village are getting stormwater done; Village and Parks are reno-ing the Golf Course. 

The Elves think it would be way cool for the Library and School District to work together on literacy and technology programming, or the Village, Library, and Schools on programming for the new Post Office site.

While Sipping Your Peppermint Mocha Lattes...

The next survey's 6 months away. See something, say something. Why wait?

  • Attend or watch their Board Meetings. Finally, all board meetings are either zoomed live or posted a day or two afterward. Always better in person, but still...

  • Research – we do what we can, but you're way smarter than us. Board meeting agenda packets are packed with neat stuff.

  • Speak up at meetings. OK, 75% of people hate – really hate – public speaking. The rest of you have realized how powerful your words can be.

  • OK, email. Remember, passion is good, backed by facts, irresistible. Trust us, they listen. Plus, you might just make it into an agenda packet.

Here are the Boards' calendars, meetings and agenda packets.

Schools

Parks

Library

Village Council

And while you're there, sign up for their newsletters. It'll really help with next year's Survey comments.

Oops, almost forgot: 2022 Caucus Survey with raw answers, Comments, Executive Summary, Platforms.

What? didn't get the Caucus Survey? You'll want this: Hello@winnetkacaucus.org.

Happy Holidays, Everyone. May your days be filled with joy and may you be the light at the end of the tunnel! See you next year!

Spot Check: FALL TOWN HALL. Wed. Nov. 16th 6:30 PM Register here. Be there. Why?

Fourteen Open Seats on the Village's Boards. Candidates and Alternates, vetted and teed up for your vote.

Seasoned incumbents, qualified newbies, and at least one challenger. If your $20+K average per-household tax bill weren't on the line, the drama alone might be worth zooming in. But that's a lot of cash to stash in the wrong hands.

You know what you pay.

In 2020 the Cook County Assessor said Winnetka's median property tax for 2020 was $20,740.37. (Yes, twice the national average.) (And no, no numbers yet for 2022.)

Most of it goes to our four local taxing bodies, hoping they'll get it right.

After months of interviewing, vetting, and voting, the Caucus Council billboarded its Most Likely To Get It Right.

You Decide Who Decides

Managerial chops, finance chops, land use chops. Meet the folks who will sit on the other side of the table for your beefs or better ideas. Do you know them? Do they have what you think it takes to make Winnetka your version of its best self? Can you trust them to spend your money with as much hard thought as it took to earn it?

Village Slate

President 

  • Chris Rintz

Trustees 

  • Robert (“Bob”) H. Dearborn

  • Bridget Kathleen Orsic

  • Kirk Albinson

Library Board Slate 

  • Travis Gosselin

  • Deborah Vandergrift

  • Ranjini Shankar

  • Matt Kinnich

Park District Slate

  • Christina Codo

  • Cynthia Rapp

  • James Hemmings

  • Jeff Tyson

 D36 School District Slate

  • Luke Figora 

  • Katherine Myers-Crum

  • Emily Rose

  • Marena Rudy

Right enough? Want more? Up close and personals here.

But wait! There's more...

The candidates that make the cut end up on the Spring Ballot. Once they collect the necessary sigs. So if one of them asks you to sign their petition to get on the ballot, do it. They're volunteers and will donate a boatload of their time to get you a better-than-good Winnetka. Thanking them for their service might be a nice touch.

ICYMI Winnetka's a Policy Over Politics Place.

There are five ways to run a town like ours: Council-manager, mayor-councilcommissiontown meeting, and representative town meeting.

Since 1915, Winnetka's been Council-Manager.

Back then, partisan politics didn't work for Winnetkans. Garbage and potholes being what they were. The Council-Manager model gave them a paid professional manager, an all-volunteer set of governing boards vetted and slated by a volunteer Caucus Council, chosen from a resident-wide Caucus whose one-vote-one-voice gave everybody with skin in the game a place at the table. Garbage got picked up, potholes got filled, and nobody had to wait for downstate.

(Proof of concept: Most towns on the North Shore rely on this system in one form or another to find, vet, and tee up qualified volunteer talent.)

Wednesday night, what works, continues.

You have until noon, Wednesday, to register.

This is a Zoom-driven piece of cake. Register, watch for your Zoomlink, log on, get checked in. Listen, discuss, vote.

In the meantime,...

New to town? Things your real estate agent may not have told you.

  • Caucus Rules - How the Caucus is organized, what it does all year, and how it does it. Fast forward to Rules 125-129 for the Fall Town Hall.

Plus, what the boards will be considering for their 2023 agenda. Caucus Platforms here, Annual Survey results here, but way more of a tell, the Survey-takers free-lance here.

Follow Your Money...

It took a bit, but all the Boards are finally posting their meeting vids. So if you're on the train, at the gym, in the carpool line, and you want to catch up, here's your fix.

Schools

Parks

Library

Village Council

Spot Check: Winnetka Park District's Workshop Follow-Up Thursday, Sept. 8th 6:00 PM Hubbard Woods Auditorium Got Questions? Get Answers?

"The Park District welcomes all feedback and will strive for transparency and better public communication as it moves forward with the project." --winpark.org

work·shop /ˈwərkˌSHäp/ - a meeting at which a group of people engage in intensive discussion and activity on a particular subject or project. - - Oxford Languages

On Thursday, August 25th, the Winnetka Park Board held the second of what was initially billed as a "Workshop." The promise: "Breakwater design concepts will be reviewed and discussed by the public, the Park District commissioners, the Park District staff, and any consultants attending the meeting."

The concepts were the Board's synthesis of the previous "workshop," and included three concepts for Elder Beach, four for Centennial, and two submitted by residents – all minus louvers, walls, or planter pockets. 

For many, the evening didn't go as planned. Visions of post-its on whiteboard, pushpins on foam core, and posterboard-mounted illustrations met dias, projection screen, podium, microphones, and auditorium seating. Intro, public comments, slide show, back up top for board-only discussion, straw pole, "the only obvious choice," thank-you-for-comings, see-you-next-times.

Oh, and we'll let you know what "Orchard" (as in the guy with the penchant for privacy and pocket planters) says when we take it to him next week.

In Case You Were Wondering...

Wait...what? No rigorous debate? Sifting? Winnowing? Audience participation? No show-of-hands? And what's with that take-it-to-"Orchard" thing?

Without discussion, the dog beach – "Orchard's Number One non-negotiable" – was back, which on paper, slammed the door on the land swap. Curious process notwithstanding, some heard the sounds of progress: No louvers, no walls, no planter pockets, no co-applicant, dog beach. The germ of a kumbaya.

But then, "Orchard." Downtown. A Tuesday morning Prez/Commissioner show-and-tell. Something about being a good neighbor. Kumbaya iced out.

Lose the Loose Ends?

It's highly unlikely the Board got two thumbs enthusiastically up on Tuesday. The reason for the meeting (and its concomitant taxpayer waste of time and treasure) moves to the top of a growing list of questions-without-answers: 

  • The negotiables, non-negotiables, and their flexibility. What's on the table, off the table, or yet to be invited? Looks like no one's leaving the room soon.?

  • The fate of the two resident-submitted plans – worked with the help of the WPD staff.

  • Why the dog beach when the 2030 Lakefront Master Plan called for it to be 86'd – which kinda got this party started. Quid pros?

  • What the Park Board Prez means when he says "no louvers, no walls, no planter pockets, no way." Side-eying a new definition of terms?

  • The fate of the land swap when residents are increasingly scrutinizing the WPD's mission to acquire – rather than swap – land when possible.

  • The validity of a mission signed off on seven economic and environmental lifetimes ago.

  • The fate of the entire issue when the Park District's empty pockets meet taxed-out taxpayers.

Where are We and What's Next?

The Park District staff is working their you-know-whats-off to get the Commissioners the information they need to get the President the head nods he wants.

According to the schedule, that includes "...using the input from the July and August meetings, staff will present to the Board the breakwater design for Elder Lane Beach and the breakwater design for Centennial Beach." Expect this to include a drill-down on:

  • A marine-based construction option.

  • Environmental implications.

  • Water quality issues.

  • Costs.

  • Funding sources and options.

A tall order by Thursday. A meeting not to miss.

Make Yourself Smart.

Always wanted to be a coastal engineer – or just play one? Try this.

And as always...the WPD Commissioners and their contacts: 

PS - if you're new to the party, we're here to help. Strap yourself in. We wrote what we know here, here, here, here, and here. We'll keep it coming.

Spot Check: The Plan, the Quid Pros, the Sigs, and finally the Money. Stormwater Solution, Giddy-up!

Sometimes you're the windshield, sometimes you're the bug. Sometimes it all comes together...

- "The Bug"

Mark Knopfler, 1992

On Wednesday, July 13th. 4:00 PM, Little Duke Field, It all came together. Winnetka's Stormwater Solution finally went shovel to dirt. Winnetka, bugged no more.

A Century of Problems – Decades of Attempts – 11 Years of Deals.

Finally, the End of our Rain-soaked, Waterlogged Lives.

It rains. But in Winnetka, the perfect storm of climate change, unfortunate geography, and infrastructure in need of some love made our little piece of heaven a place you just didn't want to be when the skies darkened and Weather Bug got antsy.

ICYMI -

  • July 23rd, 2016 – 5” in 6 hours

  • April 8, 2013 – 3.5” in 12 hours (ground was saturated. Water went overland.)

  • July 22&23, 2011 – 6.49” in 3.5 hours

  • September 13-15, 2008 – 8.19” in 36 hours

  • August 2, 2002 – 5.44” in 6 hours

It's the kind of rain that crashed through window wells, gushed from floor drains, burned out backups, and made paddling puppies and kids in kayaks way less charming than you might think.

It's Called Crow Island.

Winnetka – especially West and Southwest Winnetka – has been water-challenged for at least a century. (If you moved here within the past 5 years, trust us.) Stuff's been tried, the most ambitious – and recent – of which was a plan to dump the top, and dirtiest, 2" of our stormwater run-off into Lake Michigan via an 8-foot-diameter tunnel. Scrapped for the obvious, the Village Council set its sights west. And sent then-Trustee Rintz to check the pulse of the Cook County Forest Preserve.

Deals, Dominos, Deliverables.

Wondering what took so long? Dominos with deal-loving decision-makers.

  • Connections met curiosity. After months of our knock-knock-knocking, the Cook County Forest Preserve (CCFP) opened the door. A crack. Had conditions. Had needs. Clean your water and we'll see what you can do for us.

  • A man on a mission met engineers with cred for clean water. After 18 months of analysis and resident interviews, Strand and Associates delivered 129 pages of a cost-conscious, environmentally responsible "elegant plan" to capture, store, cleanse, and release it into the Skokie Lagoons and eventually, the Forest Preserve. Using gravity. And pipes. (No new pumps. They break, and cost.) And above- and underground storage.

  • Winnetka's built out – no land to store anything anywhere. But New Trier, D36 School District, and New Trier had lots of it. Just right for engineered storage. And needs. More knocking. More see-what-you-can-do-for-us's.

  • Back to CCFP with proof of concept. Good faith effort met good faith handshake [AKA MOU]. Lock it in and we'll look again.

  • Two storms and hundreds of miffed residents later, the locals tee'd up their to-dos and were ready to talk.

And the money...? No buzz-kill there.

$75.7MM Pricetag. 92.7% of it in the Boat.

$5.5MM to go, five years to get it, and a vow to "leave no stone unturned." Our money's on the guy who rode this for 11 years.

Not Just a West/Southwest Winnetka Problem.

You may not live there, but a lot of your stuff is on the other side of that standing two feet of H2O. Think: School, summer camp, errands, the office. If you can't get there, you can't get it done.

Fixes for the Rest of Town.

Waiting for The Solution, the Village one-offed like crazy. That infrastructure in need of some love? Found it in the $16.5MM use-it-or-lose-it Stormwater Utility Fund.

  • Ash Street got a pump station to help move water from the Ash/Hibbard neighborhood.

  • Spruce Street got two outlets – at Tower and Maple – to reduce flooding in NE Winnetka.

  • Greenwood/Forest Glen got a new storm sewer system that relieved overland flooding and helped drain NW Winnetka.

  • Boal Parkway got a new pump station that helped relieve its flooding and ponding.

  • Lincoln Avenue parking lot got permeable pavers that helped reduce flooding on Lincoln Avenue.

  • The Village's sewer and manhole system was relined making the entire system less "leaky."

  • The Village reinstated incentives for residential backflow prevention and overhead sewers.

Patience, W/SW. Your ship has finally come in.

Bye-Bye Stanley Steamer – Hello Game-Day, Movie-Night-Ready Mancave.

It's out there – another storm-with-our-name-on-it. But with the upstream fixes in place, only W/SW's water will be W/SW's problem.

Once this project is done, even that water will get gone quicker and more completely. (And according to the Village Engineers, more cost-effectively and relatively maintenance-free minus periodic cleaning and rodding, and filter checks.)

As long as your own stuff's in order, flooded-basement-generated curb trash will be a part of somebody else's script.

Eyes on the Prize.

The project is "expected to take several years." But if Prez Rintz and Co can spend 11 years getting this far, who can't take a breath to bring it home? NTL, the Village feels your pain and sends this:

What's being done, and what to expect. For the life of the project. Most of all, when your street – or one you need – will be dug up.

(Psst: If the code doesn't work for you, bookmark the Village's construction updates.)

Feeling an "Attaboy?"

Prez Rintz would be the first to admit he didn't fly solo. Trustee Cripe was also on-point. And the rest of the Village Council had their backs.

Feeling a little "attaboy?" Here you go:

Email all council members.

A la carte:

Chris Rintz

Rob Apatoff

Andrew Cripe

Tina Dalman

Bob Dearborn

John Swierk

Winnetka Park District Meeting, Tomorrow, Thursday, August 18th, 6:00PM New Place: Washburne Auditorium, Corner of Hibbard and Elm.

After a month's hiatus, the Winnetka Park Board's geared up and ready to roll.

Here's the Agenda.

Showing that they can walk and chew gum, a lot of stuff's on that agenda - like stormwater retention and the golf course reno. But if you're coming for the beachfront, here's what to expect:

  • Item #6 - Comments from Visitors. 3-minute rule, mostly. Inside voices. Additional, not repeat, comments. If you've got something new to add, rhe mic's all yours. Public comment guidelines. Forewarned is forearmed.

  • Item #10 - New Business - will lead off with the Lakefront. The Board's presenting a whopping 6 concepts and their projected costs. Check them out - Agenda pages 175-192. You have to wait to comment on them until item #14. Although that may change - Item #2 is "Additions or Changes to the Agenda."

  • Eventually, the Board will go into Closed Session to discuss a number of things, including employment, litigation, purchase, lease or sale of property. No votes in closed session, so if one's necessary, you'll hear about it.

The Board plans to topline its Beachfront Options - an amalgam of their collective thinking, best practices, and resident imput - and save the drill-down for the upcoming August 25th Lakefront Workshop. But resident comments could draw them deeper sooner.

In the Meantime, Here's Where Things Stand.


The Park Board's going solo on any application to the Illinois Department of Natural Resources and US Army Corps of Engineers, if and when the time comes. Expect the Property Owner to continue to dialog with the WPD and pitch any leftovers directly to the state and feds.

  • Louvers are out, but maybe not so much the 30-foot planter pockets 100 feet into the water and the plants planted in them.

  • No date published for the Land Swap, if it in fact is to be.

  • Legal action hinted - perennially - but more saber-rattling than satisfaction.

To Refresh.

This project has generated a lot of work product, if little progress. And the WPD's published it on their website. Here are the highlights.

  • The Master Plan - The Big Picture, including concept drawings of the combined Elder/Centennial Beach.

  • The WPD's original plan for the combined beaches. Being revised even as we speak. WPD says "stay tuned."

  • The Exchange Agreement - AKA The Land Swap that trades the property between the two beaches for a somewhat equal-sized piece of the south side of Centennial Park. The only piece of signed and legally binding paper. Although up for grabs being that both parties have failed - repeatedly - to officially call the other out on missed deadlines.

  • The WPD's timeline for getting to go. So far, they're on track.

Feeling like geeking out? Here's your one-stop shop.

Can't Make the Meeting?

To attend via Zoom, sign in and enter Meeting ID #885 7859 1317 and Passcode #280372. To listen via phone, call +1.312.626.6799 and use the same meeting number and passcode.

Otherwise, you can catch up when they post it in a day or two.

BTW - Four Park Board seats are up for grabs this year. At this point, not all incumbants intend to poney up for another term. Think you have the chops for the job? The Caucus is teeing up interviews even as we speak. Contact them for more information and/or an application - hello@winnetkacaucus.org

Spot Check: Winnetka Park Board Lakefront Work Session Monday, July 18th. Your front-row seat to one more chance. Be there.

Centennial Beach 5pm - 225 Sheridan Road - learn about breakwater design options. 

Lloyd Beach 6pm - 799 Sheridan Road - compare the proposed breakwater to the one at Lloyd Beach.

Hubbard Woods School 7pm - 1111 Chatfield Road - recap and share ideas + insights.


 Lack of transparency bites.

Just ask the Winnetka Park District.

Lack of transparency limits options. Diverts forward momentum. Keeps you on defense when you should be taking a victory lap. Causes you to negotiate with parties not of your choosing. Questions motives, tactics, commitment, and (yes!) intelligence.

NTL. Monday night is the WPD’s all-out (and possibly final) attempt to come clean.

 A three-stage, probably 4-hours-plus all-hands-on-deck, show and tell of the what's and why's behind the deal to combine Centennial and Elder beaches and parks into a lakefront amenity they'd hoped would become the pride of Winnetka and beyond.


 ICYMI

n 2016, the Winnetka Park Board approved the Waterfront 2030 Plan – the Master Plan to preserve and improve all 5 of Winnetka's beaches and its beachfront parks.

 A combined Centennial/Elder Beach was the last major deliverable. A property between the two was the last major hurdle. A resident bought it and offered to swap it for an equal-size piece of Centennial Park, signed an "Exchange Agreement" to put a period on the deal. Next stop title exchange, closing, handshake, nice doing business with you's.

Not so fast.

The property owner decided he needed privacy and security. Then more privacy, more security. Then guarantees of privacy and security. Eventually, a one-and-done with a stone breakwater became a joined-at-the-hip-in-perpetuity public-private partnership with a 17-foot concrete-and-steel wall to be constructed on his property and maintained by the Park District.

 With a boatload of sub-agreements, covenants, and conditions.

That a boatload of Winnetka residents didn't like. Make that, a boatload and a couple of newbie Commissioners who when brought up to speed (including FOIA-ing their own Commission's work product), wondered how this happened.

To which the WPD said, it's too late, move on.

Oops.

Phrases like "in the public interest," "fiduciary responsibility," "legal rights," and finally, "if you knew what we knew" ensued. Cue curious-turned-suspicious residents. Thousands of them.

 Catch up. On. Steroids.

The WPD was forced to rebuild its website to house details and documents, videotape and youtube its Board meetings, and eventually, post FOIA'd (albeit highly redacted) minutes of more than 3 years of closed sessions.

 Then following the Village Council's lead, launched "Chats with Commissioners."

 Monday night is the WPD moving on.


From the Cheap Seats

 There are a lotta loose ends. Will make for good convos, come Monday.

  • Title. The property owner says no exchange without permits. The Exchange Agreement – the only one with sigs – says otherwise.

  •  Wall? OK, no wall. The Property Owner threw it down. Not really his to toss, tho, according to the Exchange Agreement. So what is?

  •  Unsigned agreements. Think: Master Agreement, Structural and Border Agreement, Restrictive Covenant. Hundreds of pages. Tons of edits. Tons of revs. Zero sigs. And yet, all are moving forward. What's with that?

  •  Follow-the-money meet player-to-be-named-later. Something called "Walton 2019 Revocable Trust" showed up on the sig pages of the Master Agreement and Structural and Boundary Agreement. Right below Orchard 2020, the Property Owner's Trust. Nothing in the minutes. Color us curious;

  •  Too much Master, too little Plan? The Waterfront 2030 Plan's a "living plan" with a "15-year plus time horizon" to be "regularly re-visited and re-evaluated...for consistency with goals and objectives, community sentiment, and environmental conditions." We're not seeing a lot of feet-to-the-fires here – at least not from the residents.

  •  Money Madness. Commissioner Codo says we've got money and 'til December to spend it or pay higher rates. So not a problem. Just ask the Village of Winnetka, who when their Tunnel to Nowhere went nowhere, spent their $16M one-offing stormwater fixes all over town.

  •  Beach, no beach. 2020 was good for water levels, bad for our beaches. According to the US Army Corps of Engineers' latest report, though, Lake Michigan is now 25" below that high. And as the water recedes, voila! beach! So the part of the Plan that's got erosion on its mind just got some time on its hands.

    Severability. Can the Board contractually decouple from the co-applicant thing now? Who's over whose barrel? According to the Closed Meeting Minutes, the Property Owner threatened to walk away from the deal several times. Why didn't the WPD see this for the gambit it was? Section 4 in the Exchange Agreement? (Hopefully, more on this later.)

    Make Them Make Good on Their Come-Clean

 The more you know, the more you'll know. Here's your stuff.

Recently released documents:

  •  Redacted closed session minutes 1/10/2019-4/28/2022 – Grab a cup of coffee, this is a long one. The redactions may be frustrating, but you'll know way more than you do right

  • Master Agreement – the Mother of All Agreements that says not so fast with that Exchange Agreement.

 From past Spot Checks: 

The WPD Commissioners and their contacts: 

·        Warren James, President: wjames@winpark.org

·        Christina Codo, Vice President: ccodo@winpark.org

·        Mickey Archambault: marchambault@winpark.org

·        Eric Lussen: elussen@winpark.org

·        Cynthia Rapp: cyrapp@winpark.org

·        Colleen Root: croot@winpark.org

·        David Seaman: dseaman@winpark.org

·        John Peterson, Exec. Director Winnetka Park District: jpeterson@winpark.org 


You won't be able to know all they know, what with those redactions and the Property Owner's confidentiality clauses. But Monday night, you'll see what they see and hear what they say. Intelligent, informed questions will make the difference between a lakefront snow job and a real beachfront solution.

Spot Check: Stormwater Management Groundbreaking Ceremony Wednesday, July 13th, 4:00PM, Little Duke Field, Corner of Cherry and Hibbard Roads.

Join President Rintz & Co to say so-long to a century of stormwater strong-arming - and hello to 100-year storm protection for West Winnetka and beyond.

Thank you, President Rintz & Co!

This is the biggest thing Winnetka's done since burying the Union Pacific Railroad tracks. Maybe even bigger. And the President is inviting you to a front-row seat for Winnetka history-in-the-making.

We've been covering the stormwater saga for years, and you can count on us to keep it coming with backstories, background, deals, docs, and of course, analysis and opinions - but for now, it's the Prez & Co's day. Here, in his own words:

Hi Folks –

It has been a while since I have reached out to provide a personal update on the stormwater project. Good news…we will be ceremoniously breaking ground on the north of Willow storm improvements, including both golf courses.

This is the first step in completing storage that will provide 100-year protection for a large portion of west Winnetka.

We have now identified and secured nearly $29.5 million in various grants, which is money we residents won’t need to pony up.

All together, we have identified and set aside nearly $75 million, and we will keep working to turn over every rock. State Rep. Robyn Gabel was instrumental in securing $28 million, working hard to get our fair share of infrastructure funds from the Feds and State.

Even better news, the budget this community approved in 2017 (adjusted), has not increased.

We are looking forward to starting work on the Cook County Forest Preserve property later this year, once Army Corps permits are finalized.

This has been a very challenging and time-consuming exercise. Hopefully, the end result will be worth it.

The Crow Island connection across Hibbard Road will be completed with Phase 1, and the balance is planned for 2023 or 2024 pending governmental permitting and school schedules. Village Council has released the design work for this portion of the project, which includes the underground storage at Crow Island.

Anyway…the official groundbreaking ceremony will be this Wednesday July 13 at 4:00 at Little Duke – corner of Cherry and Hibbard. If you are around, join us!

The last cataclysmic event was 2011, and we have been fortunate for a stretch of good fortune. In 1904 neighbors were digging ditches on the west side in desperation from the continual flooding. We finally have traction!

Have a great summer!

Christopher Rintz

President – Village of Winnetka

Just in Case

We couldn't help ourselves. In case you have no idea what this is about, get ready to be impressed with your tax dollars at work!

  • We last wrote about this long, strange trip here.

  • The Village short-sheeted it here.

  • Want more? There's plenty in our Past Spot Checks, including the players and handshakes that got us here.

See ya at the Celebration!

Spot Check: Residents told the Winnetka Park District to Pound Sand. Here's what Happened. What's Next is Anybody's Guess.

A donation-turned-joint venture, a land-swap with conditions, an Exchange Agreement without them, 22 months of closed session negotiations, board members in the dark, proposals published but not seen, an angry vox populi, a recalled government application, a dug-in board president, a silent "silent majority," a closed-session Guest of Honor with a microphone, and an IDNR with time on its hands. For now.

Welcome to sausage-making, Winnetka-style.

It was all going so well. The plan for the June 16th Winnetka Park District Board Meeting was to listen to the residents, meet in closed session with the owner of the property between the two beaches (AKA the guy on the other end of the Exchange Agreement and the co-applicant for US Army Corps of Engineers/Illinois Department of Natural Resources permits) then return to open session and boldly and confidently announce next steps in the rollout of the combined Elder and Centennial Beach – the last Big Deal in the 2030 Waterfront Master Plan. Kumbaya.

Then the wheels came off.

Cringe-worthy moment on steroids. After more than an hour of public comments, the Property Owner went off script, took the microphone, pleaded his case to an open-mouthed audience, hijacked the amygdalae of several commissioners who subsequently engaged, offered to nix his wall (but not his plantings, landscaping, or demand that without permits, no swap) and handed out a "solution" he was certain would be approved by USACE/IDNR.

Oh, and "I'm not waiting 6 months for you to approve this."

Checkers meet chess.

Read Me In?

In 2016, the Winnetka Park Board approved the Waterfront 2030 Plan – the Master plan to preserve and improve all 5 of Winnetka's beaches and its beachfront parks.

Ticking through the Plan, the Board was down to the last deliverable – a combined Elder-plus-Centennial beach with a best-case purchase of the property between the two beaches – when the owner offered to swap it out for a part of Centennial Park.

And signed a contract – an Exchange Agreement – for a simple 1-for-1 land swap. Called "generous."

Agreement in hand, the Board and its consultants went to work on the details, including a breakwater design to preserve the eroding lakefront. The Property Owner said he needed security and privacy. A breakwater became a wall with steel louvers. With landscaping. In planters. On his property. Making him a co-applicant and netting the Park District an additional 30-plus feet of beachfront. Thank me later.

He also needed assurances this deal could get done. So, called it: Permits before property. And a confidentiality clause to make sure negotiations stayed private.

A Simple Land Swap No More.

The "gift" from "a generous donor" morphed into a "deal" with a co-applicant in a joint venture. With a taxing body. Negotiated in private. Details hidden from public scrutiny.

The design with its louvered breakwaters, planters, and landscaping was sent to USACE/IDNR for preliminary review and eventually shown to the public.

USACE/IDNR had concerns that the walls-plus-louvers restricted access and views. But residents, concerned about the loss of the dog beach at Centennial, missed the significance of the revised breakwaters.

In the fall of 2021, with the concept and Exchange Agreement finalized, the Board, with the Property Owner as co-applicant, went for final permitting. The Park Board then held two open houses to present the plans to residents.

This time, residents got it.

On June 16th, after two contentious-defining Park Board meetings, and a recall of the application, the Board attempted to try to get back on track.

What do They Want? When do They Want it?

Residents, no louvers, no wall; Property Owner, OK, but planters, landscaping, and a seat at the USACE/IDNR table, or no deal.

Not quite sure who was the rock, who was the hard place, the Board dug in:

Seaman: Let's not do this again. Two commissioners plus Park Board staff in every negotiation, no disrespect to the two who'd gotten us here.

Root: No deal until title. Stake in the sand. Get to closing, then work "collaboratively to do the design.” Until then, nothing to see here.

Lussen: Winnetka is anti-progress. "Help us get to the right spot." Optionality matters. Fix the beaches, then see where we are.

Rapp: To clarify, the Board voted on the Plan on August 26, 2021, but the public didn't see the louvers until September 9, 2021.

Codo (Board Co-Chair): The District's "250-basis points in the money" and has until December to use it. Refinancing at today's rates? Ouch.

Archambault: Cautions against analysis paralysis. Seconds having two commissioners plus staff at all meetings – for best thinking.

James (Board Chair): Expected the deal, signed in October 2020, would take "6-18 months" to closing. The contract “did not contemplate anything to do with the lakefront improvements.” Best case: Sole applicant.

What We're Watching

  • Immediate vs excellent? For all those "clock is ticking's," a little context. The Village of Winnetka just approved the Stormwater Management Project. Eleven years after negotiations began. The Park District's only been at this for 2.

  • Zero-to-hero and back again? The Property Owner's willing to go "no wall." Why? Why now? And why in public after 22 months of closed doors?

  • When Board President James says we're back to square one, which square one does he mean?

  • How long is perpetuity? If permitting is granted jointly, what happens when board members who cut this deal term out? What protections/rights/responsibilities do taxpayers and their reps have then?

  • Walk away, Warren? Many residents want the Board to walk away from the deal. The Master Plan includes an option to combine the beaches without the property-in-the-middle while waiting for the right time to acquire it. No hands tied, no joint responsibilities.

  • Most of all, those 22 months of confidentiality. And what the Board members know that at least one of them wishes residents did. Will the Property-Owner-with-a-Microphone release the District to find out? How are the Board's hands tied? What's the deal...really?

Now What?

According to Board President James, 5 months, and money. The Board starts over - or as over as it can. Pays for withdrawing the application. Promises to include public comments in the new application.

The most obvious move is to call the contract – as Commissioner Root says, "We're in our 5th contingency period" – redesign the breakwaters, move them onto Park District property, put the property-in-the-middle on hold, and go for permits as a sole applicant.

Unless the unknown knowns from those 22 months of closed sessions are lying in the tall grass.

And The Waterfront 2030 Plan?

Maybe it's time is not now. Most of it has been completed. Commissioner James says we may only have money to cherry-pick elements of the combined lakefront beach, anyway, so maybe now's the time to get done what we can get done.

Next Up - July 18th "Work Session." They promised. Time and place, TBD.An agenda would be nice, too. As soon as we know, you'll know.

Learn – Learn – Share.

Commissioner Root says "if you knew what we know..." Learn what you can. This is a good start.

  • Videos of the last two (and only recorded) WPD meetings here.

  • Video of the June 7, 2022 Village Council meeting here

  • WPD Document Dump here. Plans, revised plans, contracts, presentations, applications. Check back often. As they generate work product, they promise to post it here.

  • WPD Video presentation of the combined beach plan with breakwaters explained here.

Back by popular demand:

Lucky Strike Extra:

And where to go to put it to work:

Don't be a stranger.

Correction: Our last Spot Check stated that the next time the Village Council would see the proposed Beachfront Plan was for zoning relief. This is incorrect. The Village Council would see the Plan for a Plat of Consolidation.

Spot Check: You Said No. They Said OK. They Walked it Back. Now, the Make-Good? Find out, Thursday, June 16th, 6:00 PM. Hubbard Woods Aud.

Dateline: Thursday, June 9th. Special Board meeting of the Winnetka Park District. Standing room only. Hundreds of residents. In chairs, on the floor, out the door. Three hours and thirty-two minutes. One motion. Carried. 3-to-2. Withdraw the applications to the US Army Corps of Engineers and Illinois Department of Natural Resources. Stat.

Rapp: Yes

Root: Yes

Seaman: Yes

Archambault: No

James: No

(Lussen: Absent)

(Codo: Absent)

One for the vox populi.

Make it Right. Then Make it Better.

At 12:56 pm on June 10th, John Peterson, Director of the Winnetka Park District, called the Illinois Department of Natural Resources and the Army Corps of Engineers. We take it back. Stop with the review. We’ll talk later. Sent out a press release to confirm.

The proposal that would have combined Centennial and Elder beaches into a single multi-use lakefront beach surrounded by a steel-louvered wall is dead in the water. For now.

Rescind, Check. Regroup? Reboot?

Rabbit hole. Tunnel vision. Forest for the trees. Deal fever. A gazillion reasons to end up on the wrong side. It happens. What’s next is what counts. This is a town with a reputation for great second acts (think Stormwater Solution, Galleria, New Trier, possibly D36, and the Post Office site).

But if Thursday night's meeting is a tell, the WPD Board's got bigger problems than a dream gone bad and a miffed co-applicant. Note to self: Commissioners in the boat before stake in the sand. Then there's this.

That Hell Hath No... Thing.

  • The Board held two open houses to show and tell its plan-plus-wall – after the application was submitted to the USACE and IDNR for permitting.

  • When residents voiced growing opposition to "The Wall," the Board held several meetings to explain and were accused of tone-deafness.

  • The Board continued to negotiate in private session – allowed, if not required, when real estate and salaries are discussed. But time behind closed doors was too much for too many.

  • Claiming limited staff time, the Board failed to publish minutes of past meetings or record and post meetings online. [Note; the video of the June 9th meeting has since been posted. Good intentions meet good start.]

  • It didn't help that the new commissioners had to FOIA their own Board's work product, and they let residents know how cool they thought this was not.

Now the 1,400-and-counting who let it rip on change.org, and the hundreds who attended and spoke at Village Council and Park District meetings are side-eying both the process and product and saying what's next better be better than good. No margin.

Drawing Board? Negotiating Table? Court? Lookin' at you lookin' at options.

  • The Property owner does the right thing and honors the original contract – the Park District makes nice with naming rights.

  • The Park District takes the owner to court. Breach of contract? More like something called “specific performance.” Meaning promises made, promises kept, or the deal is off. No damages. Just get over yourself and stand by your word.

  • The Park District decides they can live with the property-in-the-middle.

  • The Park District buys the property at “fair market value” with monies that at this point it doesn’t have. Looks for an angel.

  • The Park District walks away. Hopes for a better climate one day. Beaches bluffs continue to erode.

  • The Park District fixes what it can. For now. The beach is a mess. Get it to useful until they can figure out a long-term solution.

What We're Watching?

  • Baby v. bathwater. It hurts to be on the wrong side. Hopefully, the WPD Board President will have the strength and courage to tee up this issue on the agenda until it is resolved.

  • Other voices. Will anyone who is legitimately in favor of the project-with-walls speak up?

  • Pots, planters, plantings. Necessary if no wall?

  • Juice in the tank. Will those residents-with-thumbs-down speak up and help find a solution to process or product?

Of course, we’ll keep you posted. It’s us. Curious, diligent, dedicated to getting it right. Or at least right-er.

...and the Village Council?

For now, it’s VC Out. Residents let ‘em know where they stand at last week’s VC meeting. The VC won’t see the project until – make that if – it comes before them for zoning relief. Give that a year or so.

R.I.P. or Let ‘Er Rip.

Help the Board Reboot. Here’s all you need to put a little meat on your message.

Watch

Read:

  • Riparian Rights. Illinois Park District Code – outlines rights and responsibilities of Park Districts regarding public waters and their shorelines.

Bookmark:

  • The WPD's new One Stop Shop for all documents authored by the WPD about "The Wall" including:

    • August 25, 2021 presentation to the public with various IDNR concerns and the Board's responses.

    • September 9, 2021 presentation further explaining the breakwaters and the planter pockets.

    • The October 10, 2020 Exchange Agreement (AKA Land Swap).

    • The October 13, 2020 Application to USACE and IDNR – the one the Commissioners just '86'd...

...and every piece of business the WPD authored on "The Wall" since then. Wh-hoo for transparency – if you can find it.

Now you're ready:

Remember, everyone you know is fighting a battle you know nothing about. Be kind.

Spot Check: 11th Hour change to the Winnetka Park District's Waterfront Master Plan. Love it? Hate it? The Illinois Department of Natural Resources is listening.

On Thursday, May 26th, the Winnetka Park District held a public meeting. Topic: The addition of a steel wall/structure to the proposed Elder/Centennial Beach. Packed house. Inside voices. All but two opposed to the recent changes to the Winnetka Park District's Waterfront 2030 Master Plan.


The original Plan, approved in 2016 after lengthy discussions and community input, called for combining two beaches - Centennial and Elder. 

Best case, acquire the property between the two beaches, land swap, style. Trade that property for the WPD's land on the south side of the beach. Quid pro perfect.  

Until it wasn't.

Wait...What...?

 Rock meet hard place. Somewhere during the negotiations, the issue of a wall came up. Steel, louvers, landscaping, high-fives. The WPD held a couple of open houses to show and tell what it thought was an updated and improved Plan. 

Problem was, a lot of residents thought it wasn't an improvement, high-fives or not.

 Where's the view? Where's the contiguous access? What's with that wall?

 In an online minute, a firestorm of opposition. A change.org petition netted more than 500 sigs in its first 24 hours. By the time of the meeting, more than 600 had logged in and read into the record. The WPD was put on notice.

Beautiful Drawings vs the Big Picture

 According to Warren James, Winnetka Parks Board President, years of work and due diligence had gone into the plan and several portions of the project are complete or well underway. 

Believing it, but not buying it. Citing the Illinois Public Trust Doctrine (landmarked here), among other points, Thursday night's attendees, including a 17-year veteran of the Winnetka Park Board, a former Winnetka Village Trustee, and a prominent Northwestern University Civil and Environmental Engineering Professor, echoed the public comments:

  • Bad precedent. Does a single resident get to wall off his property beyond the beach, into the water? No other home along the beachfront has been granted such an exception.

  • Winnetka's beaches aren’t for sale. They belong to the public, regardless of the opportunity to connect the beaches.

  • Short-sighted solution. The steel wall would block the public views from both the north and south.

  • Public vs private interests. The Park Board, as a representative of the taxpayers, needs to balance the public interest over the interests of one individual.

  • Short-term solution vs long-term benefit. For more than 100 years, it's been two parks, two beaches. The chance to connect them is nice, but at what cost? If the deal for the land swap doesn't go through, we can live with it for another 100. 

When one of the Board called a motion to stick in the clutch and revisit the Plan, no one seconded. So now it's your turn. 

Love the Plan? Hate the Plan? Got a question? Comment?

The IDNR is giving you until June 2nd to speak up or forever hold your peace..

Here are the people to contact:

 llinois Department of Natural Resources reps:

Local Peps:

 Winnetka Parks Board - reach all Commissioners with one note:

 Winnetka Park District

Admin + Recreation Office

540 Hibbard Road, Winnetka, IL 60093

P: (847) 501-2040

F: (847) 501-5779 E: wpdinfo@winpark.org

 Here's The Plan:

Elder and Centennial Park and Beach Project Presentation

 Here's what else you need to know:

Winnetka Park District Waterfront 2030 Project and Plans

 Check out the petition: Change.org.


Spot Check: Winnetka Spring Virtual Town Hall Wednesday, April 13th. 7:00-8:30 PM. Zoom In. Here's Why.

It's a Winnetka Tradition. 

In 1890, social activist and Winnetka resident Henry Demarist Lloyd help found the Winnetka Town Meeting. With friends in high places, he provided a forum for residents to hear from such legends as Jane Addams and Clarence Darrow.


  Chris Rintz, Dawn Livingston, Warren James, Melissa Mitchell and your $20+K.

 Not exactly names destined for beaches, expressways or source material for movies, books and plays, but way more timely.

In 2020, Winnetka's median property tax was $20,740.37. No numbers yet for 2021, but you know what you pay. 

These are the people who head the taxing bodies you pay it to. These are the Presidents of the VillageSchoolsParks, and Library Boards respectively. 

Once a year, the Caucus Council invites them to the current iteration of Demarist's Town Meeting to tell Village residents what they've accomplished, what's on the docket, and what's on their minds for the rest of the year. 

While their names aren't on the check, their stamp is all over the deliverables. They set the agenda for their boards. They prioritize the to-dos. They are accountable. 

They or their predecessors have renovated and updated the lakefront, library, and school buildings. Added pots, planters, and pavers to make downtown more like a place people want to be. Worked Cook County to take your stormwater. Plowed streets and collected garbage, kept the parks and parkways looking good. Gave you holiday lighting, 4th of July Parades, and Covid-safe places for your kids. 

Wednesday, they'll tell you what's next. 

Hopefully, stuff like plans for D36's referendum, the Village President's vision for the Post Office site and that mother-of-all-eyesores, One Winnetka (the Village doesn't own it, but nice to know of any bone fide suitors), the Park District's dog park vs dog beach thing, and the Library's plan for its Master Plan. For starters. 

Promises Made - Promises Kept 

About that accountable part. Last Fall, the Caucus Council submitted the results of the Annual Survey (we hope) you took. Each Board committed to at least taking the Platforms and their Planks under advisement. 

Considering that they're elected officials, and the Survey results were representative, it's probably good form to nod to the host. Wednesday night, you'll hear where they are on that. 

15 Soon-to-be-Open Seats 

Then there's this. At least three per board - including Village President - are up for grabs the next election cycle. The Caucus Council will interview and tee up candidates - as it did these four board heads. Expect some re-ups and some newbies. 

You'll eventually vote on them, so this is a good place to get an idea for the talent, the skills, and what's still needed. 

Enquiring minds. Ninety minutes vs countless hours of research. Informed decisions. Priceless. 

Past Performance does not Guarantee Future Success 

Enter, you. 

These folks are volunteers. They know what they know - and what they learn from forums like this. Make them even better at spending your money. Come with questions, comments, concerns, insights. Be ready to share. 

Cue: 12,428 grateful Winnetkans. 

No Beverages or Appetizers Required 

Ninety minutes with four of the Village's most influential people. Up close and personal in the zoom-room of your choice. And with virtual backgrounds, you don't even have to tidy up. 

If you're not already on the Caucus email list, you have until midnight, Tuesday, April 12th to request your Zoom link. Pass the word. 

Got questions? Submit them here to make sure they get asked. 

FYI - Boards, Biographies, & Budgets 

Stay on top of the spending. Sign up for the info they put out, and keep the Chairs on speed dial. Tap or click away! 

Village

Winnetka School District 36

Winnetka Park District

 Winnetka-Northfield Library

 We aim to please. See you there!

Spot Check: $59.4M Ask. Right Enough? District 36 Wants to Know.

Eighteen months, endless caffeine-fueled one-on-ones, a twenty-three-resident (including one of our own) task force, four meetings, three options (none of which flew initially), a new approach, new consultant, (re)new(ed) architect, and new resolve to deliver a taxpayer tolerable, referendum-passable plan for the maintenance, repairs and critical upgrades the District says it needs to support the educational excellence Winnetka expects. 

On Tuesday, February 22nd the Winnetka School Board unveiled its Downsized Capital Improvement Proposal – a 35% downsized version of its 2019 failed $90.6M Referendum.

Did they get it right? Righter than last time? Right enough to go to referendum in the Fall?

  Reboot. Revise. Re-Ref?

They said they’d be back.

 In 2007, the Winnetka School District asked for $47.3M to "address imperative building needs in a fiscally responsible manner." Voters said yes. All five schools got health and life safety fixes and upgrades like ventilation, plumbing, lighting, and ADA accessibility, wi-fi. Some got new classrooms, cafeterias, resource centers, science labs, new gyms. Others didn't.

 In 2019, the District asked for $90.6M to finish the job. And then some. Voters said no. Said too complicated, too costly, too big picture. Oh, and no Skokie School? Not a good move in a town that's been battling to keep its sentimental favorite for, like, decades.  

To address maintenance issues that couldn't wait, the District found $14.2M in reserves. Called it a Three Year Critical Facility Plan.

Then went to work on the rest of the ask.

For 18 months, the District went all green shades and sharp pencils. Focused on needs over wants. Got that $90.6M down to $59.4M. Felt it balanced critical educational and facilities needs with "physical equity" (Translation: all kids get the same educational experience, regardless of where they go to school) and tax tolerance. Ran it past the Task Force who said, yeah, but don't forget Skokie School.

 [Drill down here.]

So what's in it now?

 What would it look like?

 How does it Compare to 2019’s Ask?

 $31.2M less. Almost 35% less.

2019 Referendum·    

  • $90.6M ask

  • Total cost: $100.6M with $10M contribution from reserves

  • $1,352/$1M in HH fair market value

  • Additions, renovations, maintenance, repairs & critical upgrades for all 4 schools

  • 5-8 grades at Washburne

  • Skokie School decommissioned

2022 Proposal

  • $59.4M ask

  • Total cost: $68.4 with $9M contribution from reserves

  • $832/$1M HH fair market value

  • Maintenance, repairs & critical upgrades for all 5 schools

  • Additions for Crow Island & Hubbard Woods, reno for Greeley

  • 5-6 grades at Skokie School – 7-8 grades at Washburne

 Why Now?

Short answer: the District says its buildings are three years closer to can't wait any longer. And that its finances are in good shape. Check it out.

  • The average lifespan of a public school building in Illinois is 42 years old. After 60, they’re usually 86'd. Three of our five buildings are 100-years-plus. Crow Island’s getting there, and the core of Washburne is 53 and counting. The District says the longer we wait, the more expensive our buildings will become. Exponentially.

  • Debt. The District has none. They closed the books on the last bond issue, December 21, 2021. Pop the cork.

  • Straight A's. When it comes to Bond Rating, can't have enough. With three, the District looks better-than-good to lenders, a two-fer while rates are for now at near historic lows.

  • Reserves. The District's got 'em. Its policy sets the level at 50% to 60% of Operating Expenditures. Way beyond the “no less than two months of regular general fund operating revenues or regular general fund operating expenditures” urged by the Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA). The District’s CFO says we can go down to 40%. Comfortably.

What's Next?

 The District's done its homework. It's hoping that by the time it's time to make a decision, nobody will know nothing about this ask.

The Plan for the Plan –  

  • 23 targeted group presentations to approximately 500 residents.

  • Neighborhood meetings at Crow Island & Hubbard Woods.

  • 3 informational mailings.

  • 2 Zoom presentations.

  • 2 in-person presentations.

  • Designated webpage.

  • Newsletter – Sign up here.

  • On-demand small group informational sessions with local organizations/residents. Want one for your group? Contact the District at 847-446-9400.  

Right Stuff? Right Sized? Hopefully the Right Questions. Check Your Mailbox.

They told you it was different this time. The people, the proposal, and the process. Part of the new process – a community-wide survey – should have hit your mailbox by now. The District says don't hold back. Questions, comments, concerns – log in or ignore it at your own expense. Didn't get yours? Call 847-446-9400.

It's Their Thinking, but it’s Your Money.

 Want more? You should. Eighty percent of you do not have kids in the School District. But we all have skin in the game. The Resource Center is now open

 Still curious?

BTW – Thinking of piping up at upcoming Board Meetings? It's good to know the rules of engagement.

 

Spot Check: Village Council's Making Up – Way Up – for Downtown’s Lost Time.

Nothing jumpstarts change like change. The pandemic that brought isolation and frustration, brought the time to make them work. Suddenly, closets were purged, basements, attics, and garages became more organized than they’d been since move-in day. Bathrooms and kitchens were reno’ed (that supply chain thing notwithstanding). Minimalistic moms became internet sensations. Stuff got done.

The Village Council was no exception.

Strap yourself in. This is only a fraction of what they’re up to Downtown.


A Whole ‘Nother Kind of Complicated.

Seemed like a slam dunk. The Caucus’s Annual Survey said bury Winnetka’s power lines.

The Village’s been waiting for critical mass on this one for a loooong time. Evidently, too long. Cue climate/technology/consumer behavior and nothing less than the very future of power generation in Winnetka.

Conundrum times two.

On February 15th, our Environment and Forestry Commission (gold star if you knew we had one) presented the Metro Mayors Climate Action Plan (CAP) to the Village Council for its official stamp. Hoping to be more than just 122 pages of good intentions on bad paper, it attempts to address what Winnetka can do – alone and with our neighbors – to make sure our air, water, and waste problems don’t get worse. Or multiply.

Twenty-seven munis have signed it. We make that 28. And because our Environment and Forestry has a heavy hand in crafting the Sustainability Chapter of the work-in-progress Comprehensive Plan, expect much of these issues to find their way to the VC's agenda.

Then there's this: We don’t just consume energy. We own the plant. And until 2035, Winnetka is hand-in-glove with the Illinois Municipal Electric Agency (IMEA) to sell them electricity for a break on our wholesale price.

Our plant’s built with bonds that run to the end of the IMEA agreement. If we cut and run before that – as some other municipalities have done – we’re still on the hook for the debt.

The VC’s got some thinkin’ to do. And it's hoping the Comp Plan will give them a little direction. This issue’s got legs, but a long tail. Expect to live with those poles a bit longer.

PS - While you're waiting, and maybe wondering what's with solar, check out the Village's Energy Initiatives.

Green Bay Road Project – Forlorn Not For Long

Smelling the coffee.

Best part of waking up, says the Village Council who after years – make that decades – decided it's time to do something with that parcel on the corner of Winnetka and Green Bay. Turns out lots of people had the same idea. Embarrassment of riches, as the VC must now decide between three what-they-think-are-excellent ops to perk up that corner.

Stay tuned for coffee, croissants, and mucho matcha lattes. Follow the progress here.

Stormwater Solution - Rain, Rain, Bring it On.

The Caucus Survey called it: More intergovernmental cooperation, please.

Way ahead of ya, said the Village, New Trier, and Winnetka’s Parks and School Districts. Years of negotiating and a boatload of quid pros netted stormwater collection and holding tanks under Duke Child’s Field, the Winnetka Park District’s Golf Course, and behind Crow Island School.

Thanks to the laws of nature, water will find its way to these tanks from the Tree Streets and Southwest Winnetka [fun factoid: water from southwest Winnetka flows north - welcome to Winnetka!] to be eventually released into the Forest Preserve. Filtered and squeaky clean.

You should start to see progress defined as dug-up streets, sometime late Spring, early Summer. Waiting for final eyes and sigs.

We last wrote about this long, strange trip here. But you can short-sheet it here.

Alright, Alright, Alright: One Winnetka.

It’s baaaack…and with it the hopes and dreams of restaurant go-ers, and downtown dogwalkers everywhere. The promise: blight no more. The deliverable: blight no more. Low bar, indeed.

Dateline: December 7, 2021. Watch video presentation and Trustees’ responses.

One Winnetka Planned Development Concept Plan v Village Council. Again. The developers – new guys same as the old guys but with a new architect and financing. Just taking the concept for a test drive.

The First Time

One Winnetka 2018

The Last Time

One Winnetka 2020

So Far...

One Winnetka 2021

Last time:

  • 4 Stories

  • 90 residences

  • 15,543 sq ft of commercial (excluding Lincoln Avenue office space TBD)

  • 158 Parking spaces above and below ground

This time:

  • 5 stories

  • 74 residences

  • 18,000 sq ft of commercial (again excluding Lincoln Avenue)

  • 158 parking spaces

Conney’s Pharmacy is not in, in case you were wondering. Neither is Phototronics (that building on the corner) – but the developer plans to “refresh” its look and rent it out.

Here’s the drill down.

If the developers were looking for direction, that was a hard room to read. Too tall slash too dense morphed into let’s find a way to make this work. And back again.

What the developers came away with, nobody knows for sure. But next stop, should they decide to proceed with this plan or a revised one, is to submit a proposal to the new-ish Planned Development Commission. So far, nothing on their Agenda, but you can bookmark the Village’s Agenda Center. The Village will publish any major progress here.

Streetscape Phase 4 – or Streetscape 2.0?

That block – or two – south of Chestnut and Elm. It’s your turn. Thanks for waiting. Plus, now that residents have experienced the plan with more than stick people in it, it’s as anticipated as curb cuts, pavers, and planters can be.

Part of the Downtown Master Plan - it’s the final phase of the Streetscape & Signage Master Plan. Residents got a full view of it on February 17th at the Village's Open House. Expect more energy, more sweet night lighting, more clinking of glasses and night music as that corner finally comes into its own.

But is that all…?

Hinting that really good things may come to those who wait, Prez Rintz has dropped seedlets of his vision for the Post Office site. And a whole new level of intergovernmental cooperation and community feel-good. Color us more than curious.

Post. Office. Site. Three words with years of side-eyed, cringe-worthy history.

The Village owns it – USPS rents it. Wants, needs, wouldn’t it be nice ifs, and alternatives will be on the table over the months – and possibly years – to come.

Expect the Bennet Plan to be dusted off once again. New to Winnetka? This will be interesting reading. And that old chestnut – rental vs sale of Village property. Four corners of retail may rear its head, as no doubt will parking.

We will keep you ah, posted.

How do Things Get on The Village’s Agenda, Anyway?

Caucus Survey Platforms, pet projects, squeaky wheels, and outright problems – like Stormwater. On February 8th, President Rintz explained to enquiring Trustees, then picked their brains. Watch for stuff like the Green Bay Trail, food scrap recycling, accessible sidewalks, design standards for solar, and more to find their way on to a Tuesday night. On your mind, too? That’s why you elected them.

Want more?

  • A fun little history of our power plant. Thank you, Historical Society.

  • More on the Comp Plan as it moves through the process. For now, it’s dating the Plan Commission. Follow its progress here. And don't be a stranger. If you've got an idea for Winnetka, this could be its new home.

  • Because one man's squeaky wheel is another's eyes and ears. If you see something you think the VC needs to look into, let them know here.

You're welcome.

Spot Check: Last year, fewer than 24 residents called the shots. If you're not OK with that, the Caucus Council wants you to raise your hand.

"Whenever people are well-informed, they can be trusted with their own government."

- Thomas Jefferson


It’s real. 24/7 Wall St. said so. In 2020 – the last time anybody checked – it declared Winnetka the #1 suburb in Illinois and the #2 place to live in the US.

( We’re working on that.)

Four square miles. Four-thousand-plus households. Twelve-thousand-plus residents. Lakefront. Greenspace. Transportation. Grade A schools, a 4th of July Parade straight out of The Music Man, Concerts and Arts in the Park, Friday walk-and-wines, Soccer Saturdays and Sundays, a movie-set-worthy downtown, and everybody’s favorite, Spring Clean-Up.

Stuff like this just doesn’t happen.

This is a DIY town. Been that way since 1915 when residents, frustrated with party infighting put progress over politics and adopted the Caucus system. One voice, one vote. Use it or lose it.

It’s 2022. The Caucus Council Says it Could Use You

Read me in.

Every voting age resident in Winnetka’s a member of the Caucus. Dem, Republican, Independent, doesn’t matter. You take the Annual Survey, show up (or log on) to the Annual Town Hall, vote on the platforms and candidates, then rinse and repeat at the polls.

Four residents from each of the Village’s 16 districts plus up to four at-large non-residents who live within the Library, Park, or School districts serve on the Caucus Council. Ideally.

That’s their work product you vote on at the Town Hall.

Each Caucus Council member serves for 3 years – 4 if they get the itch. Their timecards are stamped with about an hour a month. Some months more, some months less, some months not at all.

{Full disclosure: YourWinnetka started here. Each of our members has served multiple terms, as district reps, Committee Chairs, and even Caucus Council Chair.}


Heavy Lifting for Heady Issues

Last year, fewer than two dozen residents served on the Caucus Council.

Those fewer-than-two-dozen discussed and debated Winnetka’s empty storefronts, work-from-home opportunities, changing demographics, diversity, community involvement, school curriculum, the perennial community pool, overhead utility lines and more.

They wrote and floated the Annual Survey. From 1,142 responses and an unprecedented 656 comments, they culled and created marching orders for the town’s four boards – Parks, School, Library, and Village(AKA the folks who spend your $20K property tax check) and selected and slated three Village Council trustees to carry them out.

The chances of those fewer-than-two-dozen getting it wrong – 60093's collective not-so-average IQ and road-tested professional problem-solvers being what they are – were slim. But still...


And That Was A Light Year

This year, all four boards are in play. Open seats, unfinished business. How those seats get filled, how finished that business gets, and what their '23 to-dos look like will be jump started by this year's Caucus Council.

Here's some of what's at stake.

Winnetka Public Schools - AKA D36

Four open seats and sticky issues like keeping schools open in between mandates and unions, social isolation sequelae, Referendum Redux (we’re on it, we’ll be following it, stay tuned), curriculum relevance and evolving demographics, and the nothing-if-not-primary role of the educator.

Winnetka Park District

Four open seats and implementing the waterfront reno before Mother Nature has other ideas, outlets for COVID-weary residents, park vs beach for the plethora of pups – COVID and otherwise – and eventually providing Winnetka’s duffers with a golf course worthy of their skills. Oh, and the Stormwater Solution roll-out, Duke Child's Field reno, and courts for new sports.

Winnetka-Northfield Public Library

Three open seats, the three-year roll-out of a $650,000 strategic plan some residents consider somewhere between a waste of taxpayer dollars and an attempt at a solution without a problem, the on-going search for relevance in the digital age (as in what makes a library a library?) and understanding what Winnetka thinks "library" means.

Village Council

The mother of all to-dos. Three open Trustee seats plus Village President, One Winnetka, the Stormwater Solution, and Phase 4 of the Downtown Reno (lookin' at you, south of Elm and Chestnut).

Back for round two is the Post Office site – we own it, USPS rents it, many want it back.

And burying utility lines that still blight some – but not all (you noticed?) of our neighborhoods. Roll-out, cost out, dig, done.

Finally, a problem with a solution: square footage looking for love in downtown, reimagined as co-working space. Hang on, work-from-homers, your mancave or yoga studio reclaim could be just a signature away.

Think the Caucus Council could use you? Yeah, we do too.


What We're Watching

Each year, 1/3 to 1/4 of the Caucus Council terms out. Somebody's got to keep track. We do. We will. You're welcome.

  • The makeup of the 2022 Caucus Council. Will outreach be aggressive enough to deliver a diverse, all-ages, all-neighborhoods Council? Will Winnetka’s best and most curious minds take that DIY bait and make the call?

  • Candidates. Those 15 open seats. Lots of incumbents - but shoe-ins? Not so fast. Personalities vs problem-solving chops? Will the choices be so clear they make independent challenges moot? And the biggie: enough candidates to make sure the job actually did seek them?

  • Annual Survey. Will the questions be insightful – or agenda driven – and be well-enough written to drive actionable data that launches platforms with teeth? Will the comments be thoughtful, useful, printable?


Almost There?

Ready to raise your hand? Want more info first? Contact hello@winnetkacaucus.org. Winnetka will be better for it.